Estate Mediation Simulation: Funeral Dispute Resolution
Created byT J
18 views0 downloads

Estate Mediation Simulation: Funeral Dispute Resolution

College/UniversityOther2 days
In this project, college students take on the roles of mediators and family members to resolve conflicts related to estate and funeral arrangements following a contested will reading. They will learn and apply conflict resolution strategies, legal principles, and ethical considerations to navigate disputes, considering cultural nuances and communication skills. Students will create a mediator's toolkit, dissect the will to identify legal and ethical obligations, and participate in a final mediation simulation, culminating in a written contract outlining the agreed-upon arrangements.
Estate MediationConflict ResolutionFuneral ArrangementsEthical ConsiderationsLegal PrinciplesCommunication Skills
Want to create your own PBL Recipe?Use our AI-powered tools to design engaging project-based learning experiences for your students.
đź“ť

Inquiry Framework

Question Framework

Driving Question

The overarching question that guides the entire project.As a funeral director, what strategies can be employed to effectively resolve conflicts associated with estate and funeral arrangements while adhering to legal, ethical, and cultural considerations?

Essential Questions

Supporting questions that break down major concepts.
  • What legal and ethical duties do funeral directors have?
  • How do cultural and religious customs influence funeral arrangements and expenses?
  • Who is responsible for funeral expenses, and how is reasonableness determined?
  • How can disputes over funeral arrangements and expenses be mediated effectively?
  • How do effective communication and strong client relationships shape ethical practices in the funeral service profession?

Standards & Learning Goals

Learning Goals

By the end of this project, students will be able to:
  • Students will be able to mediate disputes over funeral arrangements and expenses.
  • Students will apply legal principles related to estate mediation.
  • Students will apply ethical principles related to estate mediation.
  • Students will apply cultural considerations to estate mediation.
  • Students will effectively communicate with disputing parties.
  • Students will understand the roles and responsibilities of involved parties (e.g., funeral directors, executors).
  • Students will understand the legal requirements for completing and filing key documents.
  • Students will analyze case law examples.
  • Students will apply ethical decision-making frameworks to real-world scenarios.

Teacher Specified

Legal & Contractual Duties
Primary
Identify the three primary sources of a funeral director’s duties: statutes, funeral contracts, and common law.Reason: Directly addresses the legal duties of funeral directors.
Legal & Contractual Duties
Primary
Explain the legal requirements for completing and filing key documents (e.g., Notification of Death, Death Certificate, Burial-Transit Permit) within statutory timeframes.Reason: Addresses the legal duties of funeral directors related to documentation.
Legal & Contractual Duties
Primary
Differentiate between express and implied contractual duties in funeral service.Reason: Covers contractual duties in funeral service.
Legal & Contractual Duties
Primary
Analyze case law examples (e.g., Thompson v. Duncan Bros., Meyer v. Nottger) to determine breaches of duty and potential liabilities.Reason: Involves analyzing legal cases related to funeral service.
Standards of Care & Liability
Primary
Apply the “reasonable, prudent, and skilled professional” standard to embalming and funeral directing practices.Reason: Addresses the standard of care required in funeral practices.
Standards of Care & Liability
Primary
Recognize situations that may result in negligent, reckless, or intentional infliction of emotional distress.Reason: Covers potential liabilities related to emotional distress.
Standards of Care & Liability
Primary
Describe the funeral director’s duty to safeguard the body from loss, theft, damage, or unauthorized procedures.Reason: Addresses the duty to protect the body.
Standards of Care & Liability
Primary
Explain the legal implications of unauthorized embalming, mutilation, or withholding of remains.Reason: Covers legal implications of specific actions related to the body.
Standards of Care & Liability
Primary
Identify the degree of care owed to invitees, clergy, and pallbearers, and outline safety measures to prevent injury.Reason: Addresses the duty of care towards individuals involved in the funeral service.
Liability for Funeral Expenses
Primary
Define the term primary obligor and explain why the estate is generally responsible for funeral expenses under common law.Reason: Covers the responsibility for funeral expenses.
Liability for Funeral Expenses
Primary
List the factors courts consider when determining the reasonableness of a funeral bill (e.g., estate size, solvency, station in life, religious customs, fraternal memberships, local customs).Reason: Addresses factors influencing the reasonableness of funeral expenses.
Liability for Funeral Expenses
Primary
Evaluate the risks of relying on estate payment, including delays and contested wills.Reason: Covers risks associated with estate payment.
Liability for Funeral Expenses
Primary
Explain contractual liability and the importance of obtaining signatures from financially responsible parties.Reason: Addresses contractual liability for funeral expenses.
Liability for Funeral Expenses
Primary
Describe the liability of executors, administrators, and governmental agencies in indigent cases.Reason: Covers liability in cases involving indigent individuals.
Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct
Primary
Differentiate between legal compliance and ethical responsibility in funeral service.Reason: Distinguishes between legal and ethical considerations.
Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct
Primary
Demonstrate understanding of the Code of Ethics for funeral professionals, including confidentiality, honesty, respect for the deceased, and commitment to community.Reason: Addresses the code of ethics for funeral professionals.
Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct
Primary
Apply ethical decision-making frameworks (e.g., Klicker’s Quick Test) to real-world scenarios.Reason: Involves applying ethical frameworks to practical scenarios.
Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct
Primary
Identify personal and professional values that influence ethical behavior in funeral service.Reason: Covers the influence of values on ethical behavior.
Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct
Primary
Recognize the consequences—both legal and reputational—of unethical conduct.Reason: Addresses the consequences of unethical actions.
Communication & Client Relations
Primary
Demonstrate the ability to communicate truthfully, respectfully, and compassionately with client families.Reason: Focuses on communication skills with clients.
Communication & Client Relations
Primary
Explain the importance of informed consent for embalming, restorative work, and other procedures.Reason: Covers informed consent in funeral procedures.
Communication & Client Relations
Primary
Maintain privacy and confidentiality in all aspects of client and decedent care.Reason: Addresses privacy and confidentiality.
Communication & Client Relations
Primary
Balance compassion with business realities, ensuring services are both ethically delivered and financially sustainable.Reason: Covers balancing compassion with business aspects.

Entry Events

Events that will be used to introduce the project to students

The Will

A local attorney dramatically reveals a recently contested will, outlining ambiguous instructions for funeral arrangements and sparking immediate conflict among potential heirs. Students assume their roles as mediators and family members on the spot.
đź“š

Portfolio Activities

Portfolio Activities

These activities progressively build towards your learning goals, with each submission contributing to the student's final portfolio.
Activity 1

Mediator's Toolkit: Developing Conflict Resolution Strategies

Students will learn and apply conflict resolution strategies, such as active listening, empathy, and compromise, to mediate disputes over funeral arrangements. They will develop a toolkit of strategies that they can use in the simulation.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.
1. Research and identify effective conflict resolution strategies, such as active listening, empathy, negotiation, and compromise.
2. Develop a toolkit of strategies tailored to the specific context of funeral arrangement disputes.
3. Practice applying these strategies in simulated scenarios, receiving feedback from peers and instructors.
4. Refine the toolkit based on feedback and experience, creating a personalized guide to conflict resolution.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityA personalized toolkit of conflict resolution strategies, including step-by-step guides, checklists, and templates for effective mediation in funeral arrangement disputes.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsAddresses Communication & Client Relations, Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct, and requires students to develop and apply strategies for resolving disputes.
Activity 2

Final Mediation Simulation: Resolving the Estate Dispute

Students will participate in a final mediation simulation, applying their knowledge of legal principles, ethical considerations, conflict resolution strategies, and communication skills to resolve the dispute over funeral arrangements and expenses.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.
1. Assume their assigned roles as family members, the executor, and the funeral director.
2. Participate in a mediated negotiation, applying their knowledge of legal principles, ethical considerations, and conflict resolution strategies.
3. Work towards a mutually agreeable resolution of the dispute.
4. Document the final agreement in a written contract.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityA written contract outlining the agreed-upon funeral arrangements and expenses, signed by all parties, demonstrating a resolution to the estate dispute.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsIntegrates all learning goals and standards, requiring students to apply their knowledge of legal principles, ethical considerations, conflict resolution strategies, and communication skills to resolve the dispute.
Activity 3

Decoding the Will: Identifying Legal and Ethical Obligations

Students will dissect the contested will from the entry event to identify specific instructions, ambiguities, and potential points of conflict. They will research relevant statutes, case law, and ethical codes to determine the legal and ethical obligations of the funeral director in this situation.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.
1. Carefully read and annotate the contested will, highlighting key phrases and potential areas of dispute.
2. Research state statutes related to funeral arrangements, estate law, and the duties of funeral directors.
3. Identify relevant case law (e.g., Thompson v. Duncan Bros., Meyer v. Nottger) that addresses similar conflicts or legal issues.
4. Consult the Code of Ethics for funeral professionals to identify relevant ethical guidelines.
5. Prepare a written summary outlining the legal and ethical obligations of the funeral director based on the will, statutes, case law, and ethical codes.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityA detailed written summary outlining the legal and ethical obligations of the funeral director in the scenario, with citations to relevant statutes, case law, and ethical codes.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsAddresses Legal & Contractual Duties, Ethical Standards & Professional Conduct, and requires analysis of the will to determine the obligations of the funeral director.
🏆

Rubric & Reflection

Portfolio Rubric

Grading criteria for assessing the overall project portfolio

Estate Mediation Simulation Rubric

Category 1

Legal and Ethical Analysis

Demonstrates understanding and application of relevant legal principles, statutes, case law, and ethical codes governing funeral service and estate administration.
Criterion 1

Legal Knowledge

Accuracy and completeness of legal information presented and applied.

Exemplary
4 Points

Demonstrates a comprehensive and accurate understanding of relevant legal principles, statutes, and case law, applying them effectively to the scenario.

Proficient
3 Points

Demonstrates a thorough understanding of relevant legal principles, statutes, and case law, applying them appropriately to the scenario.

Developing
2 Points

Shows an emerging understanding of relevant legal principles, statutes, and case law, with some inconsistencies in application.

Beginning
1 Points

Demonstrates a limited understanding of relevant legal principles, statutes, and case law, struggling with application to the scenario.

Criterion 2

Ethical Reasoning

Application of ethical frameworks and codes of conduct to the scenario.

Exemplary
4 Points

Applies ethical frameworks and codes of conduct with sophistication and insight, demonstrating a strong commitment to ethical practice.

Proficient
3 Points

Applies ethical frameworks and codes of conduct appropriately, demonstrating a clear understanding of ethical responsibilities.

Developing
2 Points

Shows an emerging understanding of ethical frameworks and codes of conduct, with some inconsistencies in application.

Beginning
1 Points

Demonstrates a limited understanding of ethical frameworks and codes of conduct, struggling with application to the scenario.

Category 2

Conflict Resolution and Mediation Skills

Effectiveness in applying conflict resolution strategies and mediation techniques to facilitate a mutually agreeable resolution.
Criterion 1

Application of Strategies

Use of active listening, empathy, negotiation, and compromise to manage conflict.

Exemplary
4 Points

Masterfully employs a range of conflict resolution strategies, demonstrating exceptional skill in facilitating communication and finding common ground.

Proficient
3 Points

Effectively applies a variety of conflict resolution strategies, demonstrating competence in facilitating communication and finding common ground.

Developing
2 Points

Applies some conflict resolution strategies, but may struggle with consistent effectiveness or adapting to changing dynamics.

Beginning
1 Points

Demonstrates limited use of conflict resolution strategies, struggling to facilitate communication or find common ground.

Criterion 2

Mediation Techniques

Skill in guiding the mediation process towards a resolution.

Exemplary
4 Points

Expertly guides the mediation process, ensuring all parties are heard and facilitating a mutually agreeable resolution efficiently and effectively.

Proficient
3 Points

Successfully guides the mediation process, ensuring all parties are heard and facilitating a mutually agreeable resolution.

Developing
2 Points

Participates in the mediation process, but may struggle to effectively guide the discussion towards a resolution.

Beginning
1 Points

Demonstrates limited participation in the mediation process, struggling to contribute to a resolution.

Category 3

Communication and Client Relations

Effectiveness in communicating with disputing parties, demonstrating empathy, respect, and professionalism.
Criterion 1

Clarity and Respect

Ability to communicate clearly, respectfully, and compassionately.

Exemplary
4 Points

Communicates with exceptional clarity, respect, and compassion, fostering a positive and productive environment for discussion.

Proficient
3 Points

Communicates clearly, respectfully, and compassionately, fostering a positive environment for discussion.

Developing
2 Points

Communicates with some clarity and respect, but may occasionally struggle to maintain a compassionate tone.

Beginning
1 Points

Struggles to communicate clearly, respectfully, or compassionately, hindering effective discussion.

Criterion 2

Professionalism

Demonstrates appropriate conduct and demeanor in the simulation.

Exemplary
4 Points

Maintains a high level of professionalism throughout the simulation, demonstrating maturity, integrity, and ethical conduct.

Proficient
3 Points

Maintains a professional demeanor throughout the simulation, demonstrating appropriate conduct and ethical awareness.

Developing
2 Points

Generally demonstrates professionalism, but may occasionally exhibit lapses in conduct or demeanor.

Beginning
1 Points

Struggles to maintain a professional demeanor, exhibiting inappropriate conduct or a lack of ethical awareness.

Category 4

Final Resolution and Documentation

Effectiveness in reaching a mutually agreeable resolution and documenting it in a written contract.
Criterion 1

Agreement Quality

The degree to which the final agreement addresses all key issues and reflects the interests of all parties.

Exemplary
4 Points

The final agreement comprehensively addresses all key issues, demonstrates a deep understanding of all parties' interests, and reflects a highly equitable outcome.

Proficient
3 Points

The final agreement addresses all key issues and reflects the interests of all parties, resulting in a mutually agreeable resolution.

Developing
2 Points

The final agreement addresses some key issues, but may not fully reflect the interests of all parties or achieve a completely mutually agreeable resolution.

Beginning
1 Points

The final agreement fails to address key issues or reflect the interests of all parties, resulting in an incomplete or unsatisfactory resolution.

Criterion 2

Contract Clarity

Clarity, completeness, and accuracy of the written contract.

Exemplary
4 Points

The written contract is exceptionally clear, complete, and accurate, leaving no room for ambiguity or misinterpretation.

Proficient
3 Points

The written contract is clear, complete, and accurate, effectively documenting the agreed-upon resolution.

Developing
2 Points

The written contract is generally clear and complete, but may contain minor ambiguities or omissions.

Beginning
1 Points

The written contract is unclear, incomplete, or inaccurate, failing to adequately document the agreed-upon resolution.

Reflection Prompts

End-of-project reflection questions to get students to think about their learning
Question 1

Reflecting on the estate mediation simulation, what was the most challenging aspect of balancing legal obligations, ethical considerations, and the emotional needs of the involved parties, and how did you navigate this challenge?

Text
Required
Question 2

How effective were the conflict resolution strategies you developed in your Mediator's Toolkit in resolving the disputes during the simulation? Provide specific examples of when these strategies were particularly helpful or ineffective.

Text
Required
Question 3

To what extent did your initial assumptions or biases about estate mediation or funeral arrangements influence your approach to the simulation, and how did you adjust your perspective based on new information or experiences?

Text
Required
Question 4

Based on your experience in the simulation, what key communication skills or strategies do you believe are essential for funeral directors when mediating disputes over funeral arrangements and expenses?

Text
Required