The College Starter Pack: Choosing Your Best Financial Accounts

Created byAlexandria Ackley

0 views1 downloads

The College Starter Pack: Choosing Your Best Financial Accounts

Grade 10Economics3 days

In this economics project, 10th-grade students act as financial evaluators to design a personalized "College Launch Kit" consisting of a strategic savings account and credit card combination. Students research different types of financial institutions and decode the "fine print" of Schumer Boxes to identify hidden fees and the true costs of high-interest debt. The experience culminates in a data-driven pitch where students justify their financial recommendations to help peers build long-term stability and avoid common predatory debt traps during the transition to adulthood.

Financial LiteracyCredit ManagementInterest RatesBanking InstitutionsDebt PreventionSchumer BoxPersonal Finance

Want to create your own PBL Recipe?Use our AI-powered tools to design engaging project-based learning experiences for your students.

📝

Inquiry Framework

Question Framework

Driving Question

The overarching question that guides the entire project.How can we, as emerging adults, evaluate and recommend the most strategic combination of savings and credit tools to build financial stability and avoid the debt traps common in the transition to college?

Essential Questions

Supporting questions that break down major concepts.

How can we leverage banking tools to build financial stability and avoid the pitfalls of debt before entering adulthood?
What role does debt play in a personal economy, and when does it transition from a tool to a burden?
How do interest rates function as both a cost of debt and a benefit of saving?
What are the long-term consequences of managing credit card debt poorly versus using it as a strategic financial tool?
How do we evaluate and compare the fine print of financial products to identify those that are most beneficial for a student budget?
How does the choice of a savings account influence one's ability to handle financial emergencies and meet future goals?

Standards & Learning Goals

Learning Goals

By the end of this project, students will be able to:

Students will evaluate and compare specific savings accounts and credit cards using criteria such as interest rates (APY/APR), fee structures, and account benefits.
Students will analyze the mechanics of debt, specifically credit card interest and minimum payments, to predict the long-term impact on financial stability.
Students will interpret the 'fine print' and disclosure documents (Schumer Box) of various financial products to identify hidden costs and contractual obligations.
Students will justify a recommendation for a 'financial starter kit' (savings/credit combination) tailored to the specific needs and income constraints of a college student.
Students will demonstrate the ability to calculate how compound interest affects both savings growth and debt accumulation over time.

New Jersey Student Learning Standards - Personal Financial Literacy

9.1.12.CDM.1

Primary

Identify the purposes, advantages, and disadvantages of debt.Reason: This is the teacher-provided standard and forms the core of the credit card analysis portion of the project.

9.1.12.CDM.2

Primary

Compare and contrast the different types of credit and the credit providers.Reason: Students must compare various credit cards and financial institutions to make their final recommendation.

9.1.12.FI.2

Primary

Compare the features of different financial institutions (e.g., banks, credit unions, investment firms).Reason: The project requires students to evaluate savings accounts across different types of banking institutions.

9.1.12.CDM.4

Secondary

Determine the impact of fees and taxes on a person's earnings, savings, and investments.Reason: Students must account for maintenance fees, late fees, and interest charges when selecting the 'best' financial products.

9.1.12.CDM.3

Supporting

Explain the impact of interest rates on savings and borrowing.Reason: Understanding interest is fundamental to evaluating both the growth of a savings account and the cost of carrying a credit card balance.

Entry Events

Events that will be used to introduce the project to students

The Influencer Audit

Students are presented with three 'FinTok' (Financial TikTok) influencer videos, each aggressively promoting a different savings account or credit card as the 'only way to get rich.' Students are tasked with becoming 'Financial Fact-Checkers' to determine which influencer is a genius and which is leading their followers toward a credit score disaster.

The 'Too Good to Be True' Trap

Students walk into a classroom decorated with flashy, neon posters for the 'Ultimate College Flex Card,' promising 'Instant Approval' and 'Free Pizza for a Year.' After students 'apply' on a mock app, the teacher reveals the hidden 38% APR and a $100 annual fee in the fine print, sparking a heated debate on why banks target students and how to spot a debt trap.

📚

Portfolio Activities

These activities progressively build towards your learning goals, with each submission contributing to the student's final portfolio.

Activity 1

Banking Blueprint: Scouting Your Financial HQ

Before choosing a specific account, students must understand the landscape of financial institutions. In this activity, students research the differences between traditional big banks, credit unions, and online-only banks. They will investigate how each institution treats savings, looking specifically at Annual Percentage Yield (APY), minimum balance requirements, and accessibility. This sets the foundation for understanding how money can grow through interest while remaining secure.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.

1. Research and define the three main types of financial institutions: National Banks, local Credit Unions, and Online Banks.

2. Identify one specific example of each institution type that offers a 'Student Savings' or 'High-Yield Savings' account.

3. Compare the APY (Annual Percentage Yield) of each account and calculate how much $1,000 would grow in one year at each institution.

4. Identify 'barriers to entry' for each, such as minimum opening deposits or monthly maintenance fees.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityA 'Banking Comparison Matrix' that ranks three different types of institutions based on their friendliness to student savers.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsThis activity aligns with standard 9.1.12.FI.2 (Compare features of different financial institutions) and 9.1.12.CDM.3 (Explain the impact of interest rates on savings). Students must differentiate between where they keep their money and how that choice affects their interest earnings.

Activity 2

The Double-Edged Sword: Debt Discovery

Students shift their focus to the world of credit. Before looking at specific cards, they must understand the 'why' and 'how' of debt. Students will analyze three scenarios: using credit for a needed car repair (emergency), using it for a spring break trip (lifestyle), and using it to build a credit score (strategic). They will weigh the advantages (rewards, safety, credit building) against the disadvantages (high interest, overspending, debt cycles).

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.

1. Brainstorm a list of reasons why a college student might want or need a credit card.

2. Categorize these reasons into 'Productive Debt' (building credit/emergencies) and 'Consumptive Debt' (wants/lifestyle).

3. Analyze a 'Debt Spiral' chart to see how carrying a $1,000 balance at 24% APR grows over 12 months if only minimum payments are made.

4. Write a 'Credit Code of Conduct'—a list of three personal rules for using a credit card responsibly.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityA 'Debt Pros & Cons Infographic' that illustrates when credit functions as a helpful tool and when it becomes a financial burden.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsThis activity directly addresses standard 9.1.12.CDM.1 (Identify the purposes, advantages, and disadvantages of debt). It requires students to look beyond the 'free money' myth of credit cards and understand the strategic use versus the high-risk reality of borrowing.

Activity 3

The Schumer Box Sleuth

In this 'forensic' activity, students learn to read the 'Schumer Box'—the standardized disclosure table required for credit cards. They will compare two popular student credit cards, looking past the flashy marketing to find hidden fees, late payment penalties, and the true cost of the APR (Annual Percentage Rate). They will also look at the 'fine print' of a savings account to find 'stealth fees' like out-of-network ATM charges or paper statement fees.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.

1. Obtain the Schumer Box for two different student-specific credit cards (e.g., a secured card vs. a rewards card).

2. Highlight the Purchase APR, the Penalty APR, and the Annual Fee. Explain in plain English what happens if a payment is 1 day late.

3. Find the 'Transaction Fees' section and identify costs for foreign transactions or cash advances.

4. Compare these findings to the 'Fee Schedule' of a companion savings account to identify overlapping costs.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityAn 'Annotated Schumer Box' and 'Fee Map' that highlights and explains the most dangerous 'traps' found in the fine print of their chosen cards.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsThis activity aligns with 9.1.12.CDM.4 (Determine the impact of fees) and 9.1.12.CDM.3 (Impact of interest rates on borrowing). By using the Schumer Box, students are directly engaging with the technical literacy required by the standards.

Activity 4

The College Launch Kit: Final Pitch

Students culminate their research by selecting one specific savings account and one specific credit card that work together to create a 'Financial Launch Kit' for a college freshman. They must present their recommendation as a pitch to a peer, justifying why this specific combination offers the best growth for savings and the safest introduction to credit. They must use data (interest rates, fee structures, and perks) to defend their choice against the 'FinTok' influencers seen at the start of the project.

Steps

Here is some basic scaffolding to help students complete the activity.

1. Select the top-performing savings account from Activity 1 and the best-valued credit card from Activity 3.

2. Create a 'First Year Projection' showing how much interest they would earn in savings and how much they would potentially pay in fees/interest if they carried a small balance.

3. Draft a 'Comparison Argument' explaining why their chosen 'Kit' is superior to the 'Too Good to Be True' cards identified in the entry event.

4. Present the final recommendation, focusing on how this combination builds long-term financial stability and a high credit score.

Final Product

What students will submit as the final product of the activityThe 'College Launch Kit Recommendation'—a digital presentation or formal report that provides a data-backed justification for their chosen financial tools.

Alignment

How this activity aligns with the learning objectives & standardsThis activity synthesizes 9.1.12.CDM.2 (Compare and contrast different types of credit and providers) and the overall goal of the project. It requires students to justify their choices using the data gathered in previous activities.

🏆

Rubric & Reflection

Portfolio Rubric

Grading criteria for assessing the overall project portfolio

The College Launch Kit: Strategic Financial Decision-Making Rubric

Category 1

College Launch Kit: Financial Literacy & Strategic Banking Rubric

This rubric evaluates the student's ability to navigate the complex world of personal banking and credit. It focuses on the transition from high school to college, emphasizing technical literacy (reading the fine print), mathematical projection (calculating interest), and strategic decision-making (choosing the right tools for a stable financial future).

Criterion 1

Financial Institution Analysis (FI.2, CDM.3)

Evaluates the ability to research, differentiate, and rank various financial institutions (National, Credit Union, Online) based on their utility for a student saver.

Exemplary

4 Points

Provides a sophisticated analysis of three distinct institution types. Ranking is backed by nuanced insights into accessibility, APY, and digital tools. Projections for $1,000 growth are flawlessly calculated and contextualized within long-term goals.

Proficient

3 Points

Accurately compares three types of financial institutions. Correctly identifies APY and calculates growth for $1,000. Ranking logic is clear and based on standard student needs.

Developing

2 Points

Compares at least two institution types. Growth calculations may contain minor errors. Ranking is present but lacks specific data-driven justification.

Beginning

1 Points

Identifies institutions but fails to distinguish between types (e.g., treats all as the same). Calculations are missing or significantly incorrect. No clear ranking provided.

Criterion 2

Strategic Debt Assessment (CDM.1)

Measures the student's understanding of debt as a tool, including the ability to distinguish between productive and consumptive debt and the mechanics of the 'debt spiral.'

Exemplary

4 Points

Demonstrates a high-level mastery of debt mechanics. Infographic provides a compelling visual narrative of the 'Debt Spiral' and proposes a 'Credit Code of Conduct' that prioritizes long-term financial health and credit score optimization.

Proficient

3 Points

Clearly distinguishes between productive and consumptive debt. Accurately illustrates the impact of high APR on a carrying balance. 'Credit Code' includes three practical, responsible rules.

Developing

2 Points

Identifies basic advantages and disadvantages of debt. Analysis of the 'Debt Spiral' is surface-level. 'Credit Code' rules are vague or generic.

Beginning

1 Points

Struggles to identify the purpose of debt beyond 'buying things.' Infographic is incomplete or fails to show the cost of interest over time.

Criterion 3

Technical Literacy: The Schumer Box (CDM.4, CDM.3)

Assesses the student's ability to interpret standardized financial disclosures (Schumer Box) and identify the impact of fees on their personal economy.

Exemplary

4 Points

Expertly decodes the Schumer Box, identifying subtle costs like Penalty APR and transaction fees. The 'Fee Map' provides a comprehensive 'plain English' translation that reveals a deep understanding of contractual obligations.

Proficient

3 Points

Correctly identifies and explains primary APR, Annual Fees, and Late Fees within the Schumer Box. Explanations of fee impacts are accurate and grounded in the provided disclosure documents.

Developing

2 Points

Locates basic fee information but struggles to explain the 'Penalty APR' or the long-term cost of secondary fees. Annotation is present but lacks detail.

Beginning

1 Points

Fails to locate key information in the Schumer Box. Does not differentiate between different types of interest rates or fees.

Criterion 4

Synthesis & Recommendation (CDM.2)

Evaluates the student's ability to synthesize research into a cohesive, data-backed recommendation for a 'Financial Launch Kit.'

Exemplary

4 Points

Presents a powerful, evidence-based argument that directly refutes 'FinTok' myths. Justification is multifaceted, considering APY, APR, fees, and perks to prove why this specific combination is superior for a college student.

Proficient

3 Points

Provides a logical recommendation for a savings/credit pairing. Uses specific data points (rates and fees) gathered in previous steps to justify why these tools were selected.

Developing

2 Points

Recommends a kit, but the justification is weak or relies on 'marketing' rather than data. Connection to student-specific needs is inconsistent.

Beginning

1 Points

Recommendation is missing or appears arbitrary. No evidence of using previous research to inform the final selection.

Criterion 5

Mathematical Application & Projections (CDM.3)

Measures the accuracy and application of financial mathematics, specifically regarding compound interest in savings and the cumulative cost of credit.

Exemplary

4 Points

Calculations are flawlessly executed and used to drive the narrative of the project. Projections include a sophisticated understanding of how small changes in interest or fees impact total wealth over the first year.

Proficient

3 Points

Accurately calculates interest earned on savings and interest charged on debt. Projections for the 'First Year' are mathematically sound and clearly presented.

Developing

2 Points

Mathematical applications show an understanding of the concepts, but contain minor errors that affect the final totals. Basic formulas are used correctly.

Beginning

1 Points

Significant mathematical errors make financial projections unreliable. Struggles to apply formulas for APY or APR.

Reflection Prompts

End-of-project reflection questions to get students to think about their learning

Question 1

Think back to the 'FinTok' influencers and the flashy 'College Flex Card' posters from the start of the project. How has your ability to spot a 'debt trap' changed now that you know how to read a Schumer Box?

Text

Required

Question 2

How confident do you feel in your ability to enter a bank or credit union and choose the right savings account for your specific financial goals?

Scale

Required

Question 3

Which of the following financial 'realities' was the most surprising or impactful for you to discover during your research?

Multiple choice

Required

Options

The massive difference between APY (savings) and APR (debt)

The impact of late fees and penalty APRs on a small balance

The difference between big national banks and local credit unions

How quickly compound interest can turn a small debt into a spiral

Question 4

In your 'Credit Code of Conduct,' you created rules for responsible use. Describe a specific college scenario where those rules will be hardest to follow, and explain how you will hold yourself accountable.

Text

Required

Question 5

When building your 'College Launch Kit,' what was the most difficult trade-off you had to make to ensure long-term financial stability?

Multiple choice

Required

Options

Choosing a lower-reward credit card to ensure a lower interest rate (APR)

Sacrificing the convenience of national ATMs for a higher savings rate (APY) at a credit union

Selecting a 'plain' account with no fees over a 'flashy' account with high fees and high rewards

Deciding between the security of a national bank and the community focus of a local credit union

Question 6

Banks often use 'rewards' and 'perks' to target college students. Based on your research into fee schedules and the Schumer Box, why do you think these institutions are willing to offer 'freebies' to students who have little to no income?

Text

Required